“I’ve been chatting with Coca-Cola about utilizing REAL Cane Sugar in Coke in america, they usually have agreed to take action. I would prefer to thank all of these in authority at Coca-Cola. This will likely be an excellent transfer by them — You may see. It is simply higher!”
That was President Donald Trump, in a latest publish on his social media platform, touting that Coca-Cola would reportedly introduce an American-made model of its iconic soda sweetened with cane sugar as an alternative of high-fructose corn syrup.
Some variations of Coke already use cane sugar, together with Coca-Cola offered in Mexico.
Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Private Finance
Be a better, higher knowledgeable investor.
Save as much as 74%
Join Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Revenue and prosper with the most effective of knowledgeable recommendation on investing, taxes, retirement, private finance and extra – straight to your e-mail.
Revenue and prosper with the most effective of knowledgeable recommendation – straight to your e-mail.
As questions on Trump’s publish mounted, Coca-Cola revealed that, as “a part of its ongoing innovation agenda,” it’ll launch an “providing made with U.S. cane sugar” as a part of its product line.
“This addition is designed to enhance the corporate’s robust core portfolio and provide extra selections throughout events and preferences,” Coca-Cola reported in its Q2 2025 earnings launch.
Nonetheless, the announcement has reignited debates about U.S. sugar coverage and, in some circumstances, soda taxes.
Will customers bear the prices of Trump’s push for cane sugar Coke? Right here’s extra of what you should know.
Cane sugar vs corn syrup: What’s the distinction?
The cane sugar Coke debate raises a key query: Why do many U.S. sodas use high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS) as an alternative of cane sugar? Nicely, it primarily comes all the way down to value and coverage.
- For the reason that Eighties, U.S. guidelines, tariffs, and quotas have led to cane sugar being dearer.
- Corn is sponsored by the federal authorities, which helps make HFCS cheaper for soda firms.
Style-wise, some folks say sodas with cane sugar, like “Mexican Coke,” style cleaner or extra pure. Others really feel that HFCS-sweetened sodas are barely sweeter.
However from a well being results perspective, each sweeteners are comparable, in line with the U.S. Meals and Drug Administration (FDA).
Particularly, the meals company studies that cane sugar (sucrose) and HFCS each include about equal components glucose and fructose, simply organized in a different way. On its web site, the FDA states:
“We’re not conscious of any proof… that there’s a distinction in security between meals containing HFCS and people containing comparable quantities of different nutritive sweeteners like sucrose.”
The primary recommendation from many vitamin business specialists is to restrict added sugars in your food plan, whatever the sort.
Will cane sugar Coke value extra?
Cane sugar typically prices 20% to 40% greater than HFCS, in line with U.S. Division of Agriculture (USDA) information.
As talked about, the value distinction largely stems from import restrictions, tariffs, and better manufacturing prices for cane sugar in comparison with sponsored home corn used to make HFCS.
Latest information present refined cane sugar priced at over 50 cents per pound. That’s roughly 12% increased than excessive fructose corn syrup.
Some business teams clarify that cane sugar additionally requires extra processing than HFCS.
For instance, the Sugar Affiliation studies that the crystallization and refining course of from fibrous cane stalks is energy-demanding, whereas HFCS manufacturing, though complicated, is much less energy-intensive.
If Coca-Cola have been to swap out HFCS for cane sugar even partially, that ingredient value improve alone might doubtlessly push soda costs up by round 10%. Extra bills might come from manufacturing adjustments and provide chain changes.
Corn Refiners Affiliation President and CEO John Bode stated the next in an announcement on the group’s web site concerning potential product reformulations:
“Changing excessive fructose corn syrup with cane sugar doesn’t make sense….[It] would value hundreds of American meals manufacturing jobs, depress farm earnings, and enhance imports of international sugar, all with no dietary profit.”
Word: Coca-Cola has not launched specifics concerning the value of any potential cane sugar model of its standard soda within the U.S.
Soda taxes might add one other layer
Past elements, native soda taxes (also called sweetened beverage taxes) in a number of U.S. cities, like Philadelphia, Seattle, and Chicago (Prepare dinner County), may influence the whole value you pay on the register.
These taxes sometimes add 1 to 2 cents per ounce or levy additional gross sales taxes on sugary drinks, no matter whether or not sweetened with cane sugar or HFCS. And soda/sweetened beverage taxes don’t change based mostly on which sweetener is listed on the label.
Supporters say city-level soda taxes assist curb extreme sugar consumption attributable to well being issues, like weight problems and diabetes.
- Knowledge present that purchases of sugary drinks declined, on common 27% because of the levies.
- Moreover, some areas reported public well being enhancements, together with weight reduction, decrease charges of tooth decay and improved being pregnant outcomes.
Nevertheless, critics argue that soda taxes disproportionately influence working households.
Additionally, some research counsel that soda taxes alone might not result in substantial adjustments in physique mass index (BMI) or weight problems prevalence attributable to elements like shopper substitution to different unhealthy meals and broader way of life points.
Notably, as of 2025, no less than three states — Arizona, Michigan, and Washington — have handed legal guidelines that particularly ban native governments from imposing new soda taxes.
What all this implies for soda lovers
President Trump’s name for cane sugar Coke has sparked some debate about U.S. soda preferences. Whereas the sugar change resonates with some, the actual influence could also be felt extra in customers’ wallets than on their style buds.
Cane sugar tends to be dearer and will result in doubtlessly increased prices for customers. In case your objective is health-conscious consumption, many specialists say the bottom line is to reasonable total sugar consumption, whatever the sweetener used.
In the end, figuring out the various factors at play may also help empower you to make knowledgeable selections concerning the sweetened drinks you purchase.
Concerning a brand new Coke product line, the corporate has recommended that it might be launched this fall. Keep tuned.
Learn Extra
TOPICS
Meals and Drug Administration
Donald Trump
