Supply: Shutterstock
Every time I’m watching a very tense sports activities match with my youngsters, considered one of them will ask “do you assume we’re going to win?”.
They need a transparent sure or no reply, however my reply’s at all times the identical, and it winds them up. “It’s potential, however that doesn’t imply it’ll occur.”
I really feel the identical means concerning the current overhaul of the UK’s oldest manufacturers. This wasn’t simply any change both. This was a name-change second, for a model with greater than 230 years of heritage and a everlasting fixture on the UK excessive avenue.
Sure, I’m speaking about WHSmith, which simply in time for back-to-school turned – drumroll please – TGJones. Identical blue banner, identical white writing, identical store-fronts and, on the face of it,- the identical in-store expertise.
Whereas this has all of the elements to hitch Twitter, Jaguar and Cracker Barrel within the pantheon of sizzling takes, I’m reluctant to trigger any marketer a headache. Life for entrepreneurs is tough sufficient as it’s.
So quite than a takedown I believed I’d try a breakdown and take a look at the questions we would have to ask earlier than leaping onto the bandwagon. That means we are able to determine for ourselves whether or not that is the mutt’s nuts or a canine’s dinner.
Companies with completely different trajectories
Let’s begin the place all good advertising and marketing ought to begin. Not with the branding, however with the industrial and buyer context. The straightforward nuts and bolts are that WHSmith, till final 12 months, was a enterprise of two components: high-street shops and journey retail, with two very completely different industrial trajectories.
Excessive-street shops have been struggling like many high-street chains within the UK. Footfall decline, power and wage inflation, fee rises – all have been all big headwinds that the enterprise had struggled to beat.
In distinction, journey retail had turn into the numerous majority of revenues, and a fair bigger share of revenue. It’s straightforward to see why; folks in airports and practice stations are a captive viewers, with out a lot alternative of the place to spend their time or cash. (The pricing evaluation of this loyal Haribo purchaser anecdotally confirms WHSmith capitalises massively on the dearth of alternative.)
Within the face of those dynamics, and with aspirations for development, the corporate made the logical resolution to dump the high-street shops and deal with journey retail. The excessive avenue is dear, onerous to get to, and most stuff may be discovered extra simply and cheaply elsewhere, particularly on-line.
So that you focus your sources – time, power, cash – on the journey shops the place you’re already making a good wedge, and do away with the dangerous, much less worthwhile and harder-to-transform high-street shops.
The shops changing WHSmith are working with model property that borrow all their predecessor’s visible branding decisions, besides the precise title.
There’s a bit extra nuance to it than that, however in the event you comply with the cash, these are the massive transferring components, and for the enterprise that also is WHSmith it makes good monetary sense.
And what of the TGJones rebrand? Properly, the very first thing is that it’s not strictly talking a rebrand. It’s the model chosen for the brand new chain of shops created from the sale of WHSmith’s high-street retailers.
Considered from that angle, WHSmith has already left the constructing – or at the least the excessive avenue – becoming a member of the likes of Woolworths and Wilko as companies that struggled to adapt to the change and problem of recent UK retail.
It doesn’t really feel like that, although, as a result of the shops changing WHSmith are working with model property that borrow all their predecessor’s visible branding decisions, besides the precise title. (Think about Aldi making Cuthbert the Caterpillar muffins, however with Marks & Spencer’s permission.)
How will we begin to consider that call, which appears to be like, properly, attention-grabbing? A helpful query for framing open and productive considering is: for this to work, what do we have to imagine to be true?
Three key challenges for TGJones
It’s a very good query as a result of it encourages us to place apart our (pure human) intuition to identify danger and consider from a perspective of a optimistic consequence.
For TGJones to work, you might want to imagine that it could actually exchange 230 years of name fairness constructed within the thoughts of UK shoppers with one thing more practical.
Should you’re satisfied by that, then you definitely additionally should be satisfied that the advertising and marketing past the look-and-feel could make up for the dearth of change elsewhere and that the entire enterprise can align behind it.
And, as ever, the individuals are as necessary because the plans, so you might want to imagine that somebody, someplace is aware of what they’re doing and is making it occur.
1. Model fairness
Let’s sort out these one after the other. First up, advertising and marketing 101 tells us folks don’t care about manufacturers. They’ve bought rather more necessary issues to be doing with their lives.
In the identical means individuals are nonetheless referring to X as Twitter, shoppers will unconsciously be saying “I’ll go and get that from WHSmith” for years after the title change. This is the reason in the present day individuals are nonetheless going into WHSmith – sorry, TGJones – on the excessive avenue every single day.
The title modified and but nonetheless folks come by the doorways, in search of the issues they know they’ll discover there. Entrepreneurs may need gone “TG huh?”, however most conventional folks couldn’t care much less. They are going to, as they almost at all times do, keep on regardless.
That stage of psychological availability is gold mud – to know you can change your model title and that buyers received’t change their procuring habits.
3 ways model constructing is much like compound curiosity
That’s what being round for 230 years does for a model, and so ‘borrowing’ the heuristics out of your predecessor has a component of crafty about it. For some time. After which what?
The recollections and associations that create psychological availability should be constantly refreshed with the intention to be efficient. That’s what a model is – the buildup of recollections and associations constructed up within the thoughts – and, broadly, the WHSmith model within the thoughts of the UK shopper might be one thing like: “A little bit of a go-to store for books, magazines and stationery. And journey bits after I’m on the transfer. It’s expensive however there’s typically no different. And the shops are nothing particular, extra about comfort than anything.”
It’s not essentially the most inspiring factor, however for the WHSmith model – now targeted on journey retail – that’s OK, as a result of as we’ve already seen, it has the bodily availability sown up.
For TGJones it’s much more difficult. What does it stand for? Properly, proper now, nothing past the borrowed fairness of its predecessor. We all know that as a result of it has solely existed for a nanosecond, so there are, as but, not one of the psychological associations that make a model. There aren’t any reminiscence buildings to refresh.
And since TGJones has chosen model property which might be so much like WHSmith’s it’ll be tough to develop its personal distinctive place. It could actually’t, for instance, run a sales-driving marketing campaign saying ‘All of your back-to-school necessities accessible at TGJones’, or drive consciousness of its ‘hub on the excessive avenue’ place with out begging the query: “TG who?”
However earlier than we completely write off the branding choices, let’s do not forget that advertising and marketing is about far more than simply communications and look-and-feel. There’s loads of scope for improved efficiency and model constructing outdoors of promoting and logos.
2. Value, product and place
So, to query two. To ensure that TGJones to work, you might want to imagine that the advertising and marketing is making up for the dearth of change elsewhere, and that the entire enterprise may be aligned behind it. Is it?
It’s unhappy how many individuals outdoors the advertising and marketing division are shocked that there’s extra to advertising and marketing than what issues appear and feel like (and it’s horrifying how frequent that’s inside advertising and marketing groups themselves). However there are 4 Ps, and TGJones has loads of scope to construct the model by product, worth and place earlier than attending to promotion.
So that you assume you’re a marketer? Show it
The footfall received’t dry up immediately. Individuals are nonetheless strolling up and down the UK excessive avenue every single day. So what are they in search of, and the way do you meet these wants?
To interrupt down the opposite three Ps, merely: what’s the vary and mixture of merchandise on provide, what costs are folks being requested to pay and in what locations are you able to entry them? And from a strategic perspective, who’s the client, and the way does the mixture of these three Ps service their wants in addition to display what TGJones is?
This must be greater than a new-name-and-logo job.
On the face of it (being beneficiant, and accepting that I’ve solely been into a couple of shops) this can be a work in progress. The product combine appears to be the identical because it was earlier than, pricing is, properly, a bit expensive, and the shop expertise remains to be labyrinthine.
And issues do want to vary. We all know the established order isn’t adequate as a result of these underperforming shops have been put up on the market within the first place, and since the value they have been bought for was knocked down within the buy course of due to diminishing efficiency.
This must be greater than a new-name-and-logo job.
On the peak of Tesco’s troubles, Dave Lewis, then CEO, mentioned “you possibly can’t promote your means out of an issue you’ve behaved your means into”. It’s good recommendation, and you may’t rebrand your means out of hassle both.
To provide TGJones the good thing about the doubt, it has solely existed for a couple of weeks. Altering retail environments is an arduous job, an costly one and, given the significance of individuals to the retail expertise, it’s a culturally distinctive problem. However with the appropriate plans and folks it’s potential.
3. Strategic readability
Which brings us to our ultimate query. To ensure that TGJones to have a profitable future, you might want to imagine that somebody, someplace is aware of what they’re doing and is engaged on making it occur
The excessive avenue within the UK is hard. Like, loopy robust. Woolworths and Wilko confirmed that being a giant previous model on the excessive avenue is tough sufficient, not to mention a ‘new’ model sitting within the shadow of the one it’s changed, in an surroundings the place excessive enterprise charges, rising employees prices and worth strain make even small margins onerous to return by. However is it potential?
With some rigorous buyer understanding, good industrial readability, a kickass-simple technique and brilliantly distinctive positioning, I do imagine there’s a spot for a generalist retailer to outlive on the UK excessive avenue.
There are nonetheless folks visiting city centres, with locations to go, errands to run, youngsters to occupy, issues to purchase – ‘class entry factors’ and ‘missions to finish’, in the event you like.
So the ‘hub on the excessive avenue’ positioning, which TGJones talks about in company comms, isn’t a horrible begin level and the choice to leverage concessions – like Toys R Us and Publish Workplace – looks like a smart method to step in the direction of that chance.
TGJones can survive, however can it thrive?
Personally, my hunch is that it could have been lots cleaner to go all-out for a launch of a very new proposition. Externally, the enterprise may capitalise on a ‘new to the excessive avenue’ second, and internally it might be galvanising for groups and retailer colleagues.
Manufacturers survive and groups thrive on readability and ease, and it simply feels too complicated to be neither one factor nor one other. New, however previous. Totally different, however the identical. Now not WHSmith, however not fully not WHSmith.
However that’s a hunch, and with out really seeing the technique, it’s onerous to actually know what TGJones is as much as. Judging the strategic chapters by what’s seen on the quilt is a recreation of guesswork. There are clues, however not a lot proof or motive.
So, is it potential for TGJones to outlive? Positive.
Is there a world the place, in 5 years’ time, it’s part of the excessive avenue which individuals repeatedly go to, promoting on a regular basis stuff and providers the group wants, and doing it in a means which makes the enterprise cash? Positive.
Is there a world the place that has occurred and folks aren’t nonetheless considering that they’re strolling into WHSmith? I doubt it.
But when TGJones finds a method to turn into a excessive avenue survivor by product, worth and place, whereas struggling by on borrowed fairness from its previous, that is perhaps an inexpensive success within the present local weather. Is that sustainable? We’ll discover out.
It might have been lots cleaner to go all-out for a launch of a very new proposition.
I believe maybe the larger questions for TGJones are going to be requested outdoors of promoting.
Its new homeowners may properly be questioning, having purchased this retail footprint for £40m, is there a better method to make again greater than we put in, quite than managing the tough turnaround technique of a enterprise in a struggling sector, which appears to be like virtually equivalent to the one which was struggling once we purchased it? And so they’d be proper to ask that; launching a brand new model on the excessive avenue is a resource-intensive gig.
As an over optimistic marketer, I’d like to see the advertising and marketing story play out positively. I’d love to put in writing the story the place TGJones has finished one thing transformative. The one about how a high-street chain may be regenerated by some sensible marketing-led considering.
Can TGJones exchange 230 years of name fairness constructed up within the thoughts of UK shoppers with one thing equally or more practical?
Can the advertising and marketing being finished past the look-and-feel make up for the dearth of change elsewhere, and may the entire enterprise align behind it?
Is it potential that somebody, someplace is aware of what they’re doing and is engaged on making it occur?
Having gone by these questions, I come again to the identical query my youngsters ask me once we’re 9 wickets down, needing 30 runs off the ultimate over.
Are they going to win? It’s potential.
Johnny Corbett is an impartial advertising and marketing specialist who has labored in management roles for big company companies, startups and companies.
