MPs vote down Farage’s proposal for UK to depart ECHR
The result’s in. Nigel Farage was defeated by 154 votes to 96, a majority of 58.
The vote is just not notably significant. The principle events weren’t whipping their MPs, and so the numbers don’t say something vital about opinion within the Commons on leaving the ECHR.
The one events within the Commons that clearly favour ECHR withdrawal are the Conservatives (119 MPs), Reform UK (5 MPs), and TUV (1 MP). Throughout the DUP (5 MPs), there’s some help for withdrawal, however views are blended.
Share
Key occasions
29m in the past
Why Labour modified its stance on letting its MPs vote in opposition to Farage’s invoice for UK to depart ECHR
34m in the past
Epping intercourse offender given £500 after threatening to problem deportation
51m in the past
How MPs voted on Farage’s 10-minute rule invoice to withdraw from ECHR
1h in the past
MPs vote down Farage’s proposal for UK to depart ECHR
1h in the past
Davey says Farage has ‘made his profession by damaging our nation’
1h in the past
Ed Davey defends ECHR, saying it ‘protects very individuals who want it most’
1h in the past
Davey says leaving ECHR would align UK with Russia
1h in the past
Farage says ECHR is ‘unfinished enterprise’, and that it provides political energy to judges
2h in the past
Farage proposes 10-minute rule invoice that may take UK out of ECHR
2h in the past
MSPs debate new early launch plan as Scottish jail inhabitants reaches file excessive
2h in the past
Tories verify Chris Philp’s invoice proposing mass deportation of individuals with indefinite depart to stay now not social gathering coverage
2h in the past
Tightening Pip profit eligibility may save £9bn a yr, say Reform
2h in the past
Reform UK authorities in London would pose ‘existential risk’ to Scottish devolution, John Swinney says
2h in the past
Labour MPs sad about being informed to abstain on Farage’s 10-minute rule invoice proposing ECHR withdrawal
3h in the past
Judicial overview of Palestine Motion ban to go forward subsequent month, after Dwelling Workplace provides up making an attempt to cease case being heard
3h in the past
PMQs – snap verdict
4h in the past
Starmer declines to rule out extending freeze on tax allowances
4h in the past
Starmer condemns Reform UK as ‘Putin-friendly’, as Ed Davey requires probe into Russian interference in UK politics
4h in the past
Starmer says productiveness figures present harm completed to financial system by Tories
4h in the past
Starmer refuses to say he stays dedicated to manifesto pledges to not elevate earnings tax, nationwide insurance coverage or VAT
4h in the past
Starmer claims Inexperienced social gathering desires to take UK out of Nato
5h in the past
Starmer faces Badenoch at PMQs
5h in the past
Jones rejects declare from Labour committee chair that authorities appears to be ‘kowtowing to China’
5h in the past
Hermer rejects declare from former Labour defence secretary Lord Hutton that authorities complacent about China risk
5h in the past
Statistics watchdog reprimands Steve Reed for saying water air pollution worse in Scotland than in Wales
5h in the past
Cupboard Workplace minister Darren Jones geese query about whether or not China needs to be in enhanced tier for Firs guidelines
5h in the past
Hermer accuses Gavin Williamson of creating bogus allegations in opposition to Jonathan Powell, underming religion in justice system
5h in the past
Counting in 2026 Scottish parliamentary elections will begin on Friday morning, not in a single day, officers announce
6h in the past
Hermer says claims that ministers intervened in China spy case ‘disgraceful’, in assault on senior Tories
6h in the past
Hermer says prosecution may have gone forward beneath NSA, despite the fact that China not in enhanced tier beneath Firs guidelines
6h in the past
Hermer says, if spy case had gone to trial, Badenoch’s quote saying China not a foe would have helped accused get off
6h in the past
Hermer says China spy prosecutions would have gone forward if Nationwide Safety Act had been handed ealier
7h in the past
Lord Hermer says, as soon as China prosecution initially accredited, lawyer normal had no additional position in CPS selections
7h in the past
Lord Hermer, lawyer normal, provides proof to committee on China spy case
7h in the past
Authorities suffers 5 defeats in Lords as ‘ping pong’ begins over employment rights invoice
7h in the past
Boris Johnson accredited China’s London super-embassy proposal in 2018
7h in the past
Shabana Mahmood says Dwelling Workplace not prepared for all challenges, because it says unlawful working arrests at file stage
Present key occasions solely
Please activate JavaScript to make use of this function
A reader asks:
What has occurred to the abolition of hereditary friends invoice?
The invoice has gone by the Commons and the Lords, the place friends handed a sequence of amendments that may undermine the invoice. Certainly one of them would permit all of the hereditary friends to remain, however would steadily phased them out over time by ending the system for Lord byelections to fill gaps left when a hereditary peer dies. MPs voted to take out these amendments in September. So the invoice is heading again to the Lords for “ping pong”.
However, virtually two months after these Commons votes, the Lords haven’t set a date for his or her subsequent debate.
I presume authorities enterprise managers are going to depart hereditary friends “ping pong” till nearer the tip of the session, to allow them to run down the clock and use that as a way of getting friends to agree.
Friends love nothing greater than debating Lords reform, and I presume the whips are frightened that, in the event that they schedule “ping pong” now, friends will waste all their time debating this invoice and never get the rest completed.
Share
Why Labour modified its stance on letting its MPs vote in opposition to Farage’s invoice for UK to depart ECHR
Peter Walker
Peter Walker is the Guardian’s senior political correspondent.
The vote by 63 Labour MPs in opposition to Nigel Farage’s ten-minute rule invoice on the UK leaving the European conference on human rights – with out which the Commons would have backed the invoice – occurred as a result of just a few Labour backbenchers warned whips and the social gathering hierarchy that they needed to act.
Whereas 10-minute rule payments don’t have any likelihood of changing into regulation with out subsequent authorities backing, MPs together with Stella Creasy warned that permitting Farage’s invoice to be handed would ship a horrible sign to European neighbours, who wouldn’t essentially perceive the purely symbolic impression of the vote.
The preliminary instruction to Labour MPs was to not vote. After a pushback, this was amended to say that whereas frontbenchers ought to do that, these on the backbenches may vote in the event that they needed.
“To let such a invoice cross at a time of sensitivity in negotiations over our European deal can be taken badly,” Creasy mentioned.
Share
Epping intercourse offender given £500 after threatening to problem deportation
A convicted youngster intercourse offender mistakenly launched from jail after arriving within the UK in a small boat was given £500 of public cash as he was deported again to Ethiopia, Rajeev Syal and Pippa Crerar report.
Share
How MPs voted on Farage’s 10-minute rule invoice to withdraw from ECHR
The division lists are out.
The 95 MPs voting for Farage’s proposal to depart the ECHR got here from:
The Conservatives: 87
Reform UK: 3
DUP: 2
Independents: 2 (Rupert Lowe and Patrick Spencer)
TUV: 1
And the 155 MPs voting in opposition to got here from:
Lib Dems: 64
Labour: 63
Independents: 10
SNP: 7
Plaid Cymru: 4
Inexperienced social gathering: 4
Alliance: 1
SDLP: 1
UUP: 1
Share
MPs vote down Farage’s proposal for UK to depart ECHR
The result’s in. Nigel Farage was defeated by 154 votes to 96, a majority of 58.
The vote is just not notably significant. The principle events weren’t whipping their MPs, and so the numbers don’t say something vital about opinion within the Commons on leaving the ECHR.
The one events within the Commons that clearly favour ECHR withdrawal are the Conservatives (119 MPs), Reform UK (5 MPs), and TUV (1 MP). Throughout the DUP (5 MPs), there’s some help for withdrawal, however views are blended.
Share
Davey says Farage has ‘made his profession by damaging our nation’
Right here is one other extract from Ed Davey’s speech in defence of the ECHR.
The European Conference and its British twin, the Human Rights Act, have introduced justice for our folks, protected them from gross misconduct and unfair therapy.
These legal guidelines assist people maintain the highly effective to account, to carry governments to account.
These legal guidelines can get justice when the elite and highly effective cowl up and abuse their energy.
So it’s clear, isn’t it? [Farage] isn’t about standing up for the person, for the abnormal individual, for the folks with no voice. [Farage] is the good friend of the elite and the highly effective.
And if we don’t defend our human rights right here at residence, how can we probably persuade different nations of the significance of human rights for their very own folks?
If we do what Reform desires, the most important cheers will come from the Kremlin and from Beijing, from Tehran, from Pyongyang, and from dictators and authoritarian regimes the world over. That may be a betrayal of all the pieces our nation stands for.
Davey additionally attacked Farage over Brexit.
[Farage] has made his profession by damaging our nation. I keep in mind how he led the marketing campaign for Brexit along with his Conservative associates. And we all know what a complete mess that’s turned out to be.
He and his associates argued Brexit would lower immigration, however immigration has gone up due to this. Simply take a look at how badly he’s betrayed the folks he claims to talk for. Brexit made the small boats disaster doable.
Share
The 2 MPs appearing as tellers for the ayes are Danny Kruger (Reform UK) and John Whittingdale (Conservative).
The 2 tellers for the noes are each Liberal Democrats: Wendy Chamberlain, the chief whip, and Claire Younger.
Share
Davey has completed his speech, and MPs at the moment are voting.
Labour MPs have now been informed they’ll vote in opposition to the Farage invoice, Peter Walker stories.
I’m now informed that govt whips have informed Labour MPs they *can* vote in opposition to the Farage 10-minute rule invoice if they need.
(Possibly our earlier reporting prompted a rethink?)
Share
Ed Davey defends ECHR, saying it ‘protects very individuals who want it most’
Davey says the ECHR “protects the very individuals who want it most”. He goes on:
Our aged and most susceptible. So they could reside and develop previous with dignity. Our youngsters. So these going through horrific abuse have higher safety.
It additionally upholds our freedom of speech in order that the press and public can criticise these in energy with out worry. And it protects our peaceable proper of protest.
Seventy years in the past, Britain grew to become the primary nation to ratify the conference as a number one voice on the worldwide stage for human rights and the rule of regulation. That’s our historical past. That’s who we’re. That’s Britain at our greatest.
Share
Davey says leaving ECHR would align UK with Russia
Ed Davey, the Lib Dem chief, is responding to Farage.
He says Farage’s speech “completely misrepresents the European conference”.
Farage didn’t point out the advantages of the ECHR, he says.
He goes on:
Let me give them one sturdy cause to assume once more. Russia beneath Vladimir Putin is the one nation to have withdrawn from the European conference on human rights.
Now, possibly that’s what attracts [Farage] to it. In any case, he mentioned, the world chief he most admires Russia, a rustic the place those that oppose the regime are mysteriously pushed off balconies, the place, if it isn’t sufficient to homicide a political opponent like Alexei Navalny.
Share
Farage is now enduring sustained heckling from the Liberal Democrats.
He says he has by no means seen so many Lib Dems within the chamber.
He concludes:
You don’t consider this nation is nice sufficient to make its personal legal guidelines.
Do you not consider a rustic that has Magna Carta and developed the precept of frequent regulation … you don’t consider we’re ok to make these guidelines?
Share
Farage says ECHR is ‘unfinished enterprise’, and that it provides political energy to judges
Farage says ECHR withdrawal is “unfinished enterprise”.
He says the vote for Brexit was “the most important democratic train within the historical past of those islands”.
We all know that we voted clearly by an enormous margin for the British folks to convey again the sovereignty … It’s the sovereignty of this very chamber and the folks inside it to convey energy again to this very place. And that’s what we voted for.
The vote was additionally prompted by “deep alarm on the large numbers of individuals coming into our nation”, he says.
Open borders have made the UK poorer, he says.
He says Tony Blair enshrined the European conference on human rights (ECHR) into UK regulation.
Now, I consider that Brexit can’t be full whereas we’re topic to a international court docket.
And he says the ECHR is regulation the place “judges can select their very own political interpretation”.
He goes on:
I don’t consider that it’s proper that we must always, in relation to controlling our borders, in relation to who ought to give you the option legally to reside, work and settle on this nation, or certainly who shouldn’t be allowed to remain in our nation, for this to be beneath the remit, firstly of judges in Strasbourg, who, by the way in which, are jurists, most of them not even legally certified, and secondly, beneath the political management of judges on this nation who now could make their very own interpretation of what we’ve understood for a lot of, a few years to be British frequent regulation.
Share
Farage proposes 10-minute rule invoice that may take UK out of ECHR
Within the Commons Nigel Farage is now proposing his invoice.
The Labour benches are virtually empty.
The Conserative benches are pretty empty too.
However the Liberal Democrats, and different opposition MPs from smaller events, are out in drive.
As Farage will get going, there’s numerous heckling. “Kids, be quiet,” he says, which prompts an intervention from the deputy Speaker.
Share
Within the Commons Seamus Logan (SNP) is utilizing a degree of order to complain about Steve Reed, the housing secretary, and former setting secretary, making deceptive statements in regards to the high quality of Scottish water. (See 11.28am.)
Judith Cummins, the deputy Speaker, mentioned that she was certain the federal government would have registered Logan’s level.
Share
MSPs debate new early launch plan as Scottish jail inhabitants reaches file excessive
Libby Brooks
Libby Brooks is the Guardian’s Scotland correspondent.
MSPs are debating whether or not to approve the additional early launch of prisoners as Scotland’s jail inhabitants reaches the very best stage ever recorded and frontline jail officers warn that the day-to-day challenges of managing overcrowding have introduced them to disaster level.
Earlier this week, the Scottish Jail Service mentioned the jail inhabitants was at a file excessive, with 8,430 folks behind bars. In a bid to ease overcrowding, the early launch of prisoners laws have been debated by Holyrood’s prison justice committee this morning, with MSPs set to vote on their suggestions at a later date. If accredited this would be the third early launch over the previous two years.
Scottish Jail Service chief govt Teresa Medhurst warned that the inhabitants had now reached a stage “that raises very severe considerations round our capacity to maintain folks protected and safe”.
This was echoed by a brand new report from the Jail Officers’ Affiliation, describing fears for their very own security and that of inmates. Phil Fairlie, the assistant normal secretary of the POA, mentioned:
The largest fear for us simply now could be employees, I believe, really feel unsafe contained in the prisons, I don’t assume they really feel they’ve received correct management. I don’t imply that the prisons are uncontrolled, however they’re working their socks off each single day to try to preserve that management.
The constructing of a £1bn jail to switch Glasgow’s HMP Barlinnie has confronted a number of delays, with the present opening date of 2028 now doubtful. The Jail Service has additionally described how profitable prosecution of great organised crime teams has left jail officers going through “a each day recreation of chess” with the intention to preserve violent rivals aside.
Share
